- The Shape of Work
- Posts
- Performance Review Over?
Performance Review Over?
Good review, bad news? Let’s unpack the latest in performance appraisals.
Hey there,
Okay, let's be real – performance reviews. Some people love 'em, some people... not so much. And then there are those who just tick the boxes and move on. But as HR folks, we know things are changing, right?
So, let's get down to it.
👀 When Your Performance Review is Public
Okay, picture this: everyone at your company can read your performance review. Wild, right? That's what Garner Health does! Their thinking? More accountability and straight-up communication.
On the one hand, employees are saying it's leading to super honest feedback and transparency. Like, no more sugarcoating.
But then, there's the other side. Some folks are worried it could create a vibe of fear and actually hurt trust. What do you guys think? Is this the future, or a recipe for disaster?
Would this work in your company, or is it a step too far? 🚀
🚨 Good Reviews, But Still Laid Off?
So, Meta laid off 4,000 people, even those with stellar performance reviews. Let that sink in. You do everything right, and you still get the boot.
Employees are asking the right questions: if performance isn't the deciding factor, then what is? And what does this mean for the future of performance evaluations in our industry? Are they just meaningless now?
📉 Performance Reviews or Just Layoffs in Disguise?
So, ShareChat's big on "raising the bar" through performance reviews. Apparently, those job cuts? Just a regular performance thing.
Totally not layoffs. They say it's only a small group of employees, twice a year.
But, come on. A lot of people in a short period? That's a lot of "raising the bar." Is this actually a legit appraisal system, or are they just playing semantics? Because, let's face it, it smells like layoffs.
Is this the future of performance management, or does it blur the line between reviews and restructuring?
🚀 Community Discussion Recap
So, performance reviews, right? We know they're supposed to be good, but honestly, they're often a headache. Fairness, recognition, and tools that don't suck? Yeah, we're all looking for that.
We recently had a really cool discussion with 40+ members, and they spilled the tea on their experiences. They shared their challenges, their wins, and some really helpful tips. Here's what they said:
Tools are Your Friends: Platforms like JIRA, Profit.co, Workday, and ADP Workforce are making reviews way easier for teams.
Peer Recognition FTW: Getting your team to recognize each other helps level the playing field. And cultural champions are awesome.
Questions Are Key: Asking the right questions can make sure everyone gets seen, even the quiet ones.
The Right Cadence: A mix of monthly, quarterly, and annual reviews seems to be the sweet spot for feedback.

And here are the questions that got us thinking:
Yunus Asad: "How do we measure if our tools are actually working?"
Nashitah Godiwala: "How do we do monthly one-on-ones with tech teams?"
Namrata: "How do we reduce bias in performance reviews and fairly assess introverted employees?”
Advertisement
🚀 HR Playbook 2.0 is shaping up to be powerful!
HR champions, we see you.
New tech, shifting expectations, and the never-ending mission to build a great workplace? It’s a lot. And for us in HR, staying ahead of the curve isn’t just an option—it’s a must.
On April 23, we’re bringing back The Shape of Work: HR Playbook 2.0.
✔️ 7 cutting-edge sessions, 15+ expert speakers—no fluff, just real insights.
✔️ One certificate (yes, you can flex it on LinkedIn).
📩 Are You 100% Compliant?[Free Resource]
58% of HR professionals feel confident about compliance - but what about the rest? With AI, gig work, and new labor laws transforming HR, compliance is no longer just a legal checkbox - it’s a business necessity.
That’s why we asked 700+ HR leaders about the real compliance challenges they face - and how they solve them - and created an ebook out of it.
🚀 Get the full report here: [Link]
🦾 The Future of HR Needs You!
From unexpected layoffs to radical transparency, performance reviews are making headlines. But are they actually helping employees grow?
Join the conversation! Share your experiences, debate the trends, and connect with HR pros who are reshaping the future of work. Let’s build a smarter, fairer workplace—together. 🚀
Join 21,000 of the brightest HR minds from across the country as we shape the future of work—one game-changing conversation at a time.
Your insights won’t just add value; they’ll drive impact for the millions of employees who count on us to get it right.
📆From Talk to Action: Let’s Shape HR Together
Step away from the screen and step into meaningful conversations! Join in-person HR events where ideas spark, insights flow, and connections turn into opportunities.
Let’s reimagine the future of work—one real conversation at a time!
✅ TSOW HR Meetup in Hyderabad: Saturday, April 12
Hyderabad, are you ready for an evening of networking, fresh ideas, and growth? Connect with top HR pros, enjoy free coffee, and earn a digital certificate to flaunt. Don’t miss out—Sign up today!
✅ TSOW HR Meetup in Mumbai: Sunday, April 13
Are you all set for an amazing evening of networking, new ideas, and growth in Mumbai? Connect with HR pros, enjoy free snacks and coffee, and snag a digital certificate to flaunt. Register now
✅TSOW HR Meetup in Bangalore: Saturday, April 19
HR leaders and enthusiasts in Bangalore—this one’s for you! Join us for an engaging meetup filled with insightful discussions, networking opportunities, and refreshments. Plus, earn a certificate to add to your achievements. Don’t miss out—Join now!
✅TSOW HR Meetup in Pune: Saturday, April 26
Pune HR pros, this is your moment! Join us for a power-packed meetup featuring insightful discussions, networking, and refreshments. Plus, grab a certificate to showcase your achievements. Secure your spot today!
Before you go… let’s be real!
Performance reviews can be a mixed bag—some are helpful, others just leave you wondering. What’s the most frustrating part for you?
What’s the Worst Part of Performance Reviews? |
And that's a wrap on this edition,
We'll be back in your inbox soon with more insights, hot takes, and the latest HR chatter to keep you ahead of the curve.
Until then, keep challenging the status quo, keep pushing for positive change, and keep shaking things up! The future of HR is in our hands! 🚀
Catch you next time,
Team TSOW 🚀